I hate this when it happens. You know those two cases for the iPhone I ordered up last week? Well, they arrived on the same day and I was hoping I'd find a clear winner but no, what happens is that they both have good and bad points and if one had the other's good points it would be really ideal when added to its won good stuff and vice versa. Drat.
First up is the Seido rubberised hard case. This is the better fit of the two and the nicer material, it reminds me of the treo 750 casing, slightly rubbery but not wet and slimy feeling like most silicon cases I have tried. Nope, it feels good to hold, sticky without being...sticky. It hardly adds any girth or depth to the iPhone and has the advanatge, in my view, of hiding the silver/black combo on the back of it. It comes in two bits, a top and a bottom which just clip together. It feels sturdy to the extent where it's a bummer to get off. There is a bit of slack though on the left hand side, if you push down on it ever so slightly you can feel it flex. That's the trouble with cases that come in bits as opposed to all in one jobs, there is always the risk that when put together it won't fit as well as a one-piecer.
What I don't like about it and this is an entirely personal thing is that it covers the top 1cm off the screen and the bottom 1cm although obviously it has cutouts for the home button and grill thing. I just think it looks a bit odd although accessing the home button is no problem at all. Another bad thing, with the case on it cannot be docked even in the universal dock...sure it will sit there looking nice but it won't charge.
As for the Agent 18 case...it is made from recycled materials which is great but the case feels quite plasticky and is not as nice to hold in the hand as the Seido effort. This one comes in two bits as well but differently, you slide them together from the top and bottom of the iphone. They sort of click together in the middle. Mine feels slightly loose at the bottom left hand corner and where they join there is slight movement. This is irritating and leaves me thinking it's not a well made case. Another irritation is that on the back they have printed "Agent 18" in less than discrete lettering and have covered over the apple logo with their own tree logo. I don't like doing free advertising for firms, I've paid the money, full price, and I don't see why I should walk around being basically a free advert for them.
So the Seido case is a better overall fit (lesser of two evils here though) and nicer to hold but......the Agent 18 one comes with a black dock adaptor for the universal one which, when inserted, enables the iPhone to be docked and charged. The case is also slightly thinner all round and has no cover on the front at all. I think it looks better on the iPhone than the Seido one but it does not feel as well made. Interestingly, the Seido case also docks and charges using the Agent18 dock adaptor. The Seido case is harder to get off whilst the Agent18, mostly due to the fact it feels looser, is the easier to get on and off.
I've used them now for a few days and have swopped them about. I can't decide which one is the better of the two and to be honest, I'm thinking of just going back to the au naturel look of the iPhone. That's the problem I find with cases...I see them advertised and think they look great and then when I get them I just end up quickly disappointed. The only case I have ever stuck with is the PDAir metal case I bought for the TX nearly two years ago. I always leave the TX in there and that is probably because it is not a phone and thus it doesn't need to be pulled out every hour or so, if it did I probably would not use a case in the first place.
"Disappointed"
Edinburgh